On a recent trip to southern Africa (Zambia/Zimbabwe) I
encountered many people who were starving and living in deplorable conditions.
I have often wondered whether foreign aid has succeeded in making Africa better
or if it deters progress.
I think that
wealthy countries need to involve the people of recipient nations about
decisions concerning poverty reduction with foreign aid. Research on this
complex issue has exposed the fact that money sent to combat poverty is often
channeled to other areas such as managing the environment, controlling illicit
drugs and the AIDS crisis instead. It has been shown that aid from abroad seems
to promote dependency on others and creates the impression that the emergence
from poverty depends on external donations rather than on people’s own efforts
and motivation. Sadly, widespread corruption, political instability and war in
many African countries, is standing in the way of the good governance that is
needed for long-term sustainable solutions.
Wealthy countries that provide foreign aid need to stop
encouraging a dependent culture that fuels corruption and contributes to
underdevelopment- this instigates conflict in Africa (Moyo, 2009). Food aid, for example, can be
destructive on the economy of a recipient nation and can contribute to more
hunger and poverty in the long run.
Free or subsidized food, below market prices undercuts local farmers,
who cannot compete and are driven out of jobs and into poverty. It seems that
some powerful nations have used this as a foreign policy tool - for dominance
that guarantees economic failure in poor regions rather than real aid.
Let’s start helping Africans with the right kind of aid in a
culturally sensitive way so they can improve their standard of living and begin
to make it on their own.
I really like how you brought up the fact that wealthy countries need to stop encouraging a dependent culture that fuels corruption and contribues to underdevelopment! I really think that wealthier nations need to really start to step it up and help these developing nations to stand on their own two feet!
ReplyDeleteI think it's amazing that you went on a trip to Africa and can speak through real experience through this blog post! I definitely agree that while it's easy to promote advocacy for "helping those less fortunate" we have to realistically think about what good our "help" is doing. The dependancy of developing nations on developed nations is definitely a great concern in the attempts to lend aid. As I have stated previously on your blog posts, I agree wholeheartedly that food dumping yields the opposite result as it should/is meant to.
ReplyDelete